Some of our more astute listeners will have no doubt caught on to the infamous Star Trek/Star Wars debate that occasionally rages between our resident Star Wars fan, Adam, and our resident Star Trek fan and host of our show, Matt Record. While my intentions are merely to settle a rivalry between friends, the implication of this debate reaches well beyond our meager radio show.
Which really is the better show? This is the question that I’ve decided to weigh in on. Armed with a mix of passing interest and general apathy for both Star Wars and Star Trek, my own two mitts, wikipedia, and the knowledge that I will alternatively annoy or greatly amuse Matt or Adam, I set out on my quest.
Choosing a number of different topics, I will dissect the two series, get to the real core and meat of what both are about, than completely disregard that, and compare and contrast them on a superficial basis. In some cases I may choose to specify the series. Some may say this is unfair, as the recent Star Wars prequels are both much newer and possessed of a bigger budget than almost anything Star Trek has put out, but really, those movies sucked so fucking bad, they pretty much handicapped themselves.
Anyway, on to the first few topics!
Long Time Ago vs. The Final Frontier
-”Space, the Final Frontier…”- A firmly held belief established during our own frontier times tells us that if we should ever run low on resources, it is our every right to expand outward, exterminating every proud heritage and peaceful creature of the wild that even so much as looks at us the wrong way. According to Gene Roddenberry, humans have done this so much that we can only continue to further ruining environments and destroying cultures if we band together and launch out into space. Sure, the crew of the enterprise are supposed to be “Science Explorers” on a “peaceful” mission, but Picard isn’t just packing hospitality in those blankets he sent to the Romulan capital, no sir. And Captain Kirk? There’s a reason he’s known throughout the Vulcan empire as “Space Cortes”.
-“A Long Time Ago, in a Galaxy Far, Far Away.”- So basically, at some point in the past man knew magic, killed each other with lasers, drove hover cars, owned spaceships and had robot butlers. Fast forward a few generations and some enterprising people (Probably from Coruscant or Cloud City) invented Fox News, reality TV, and those Geico commercials about the cavemen, all meet great success. Fast forward some more generations, and our ancestors are running out of caves in the middle of thunderstorms, killing each other over the title of “Ugh Uhkk, Oogh Ark”, loosely translated as “Finders Keepers, Losers Weepers” for some fire. Well human progress has gotten us half the way back to how things used to be, unfortunately, it’s not the half with telekinesis and lasers.
… I think I’m gonna give this one to Star Trek, if only because George Lucas is basically implying “Look, you had all this awesome shit, but you HAD to screw it up, didn’t you?”. Plus, Star Trek’s idea that we are more high tech in the future than in the past seems more linear and therefore sensible to me, at least until we find an X-wing or medic droid somewhere in the fossil record.
Lightsaber vs. Phaser
Fact: Kids love to kill things. Fact: Lightsabers kill things good. Fact: Every kid ever wants a lightsaber to kill things with. Admit it, you STILL want a lightsaber to kill shit with. It’s probably the coolest thing never actually invented and when you were little all you wanted was your own plastic one so you could show your friend Jeremy who the REAL Jedi master of the playground was. PROVE ME WRONG.
On the other hand, I really doubt any kids were thinking “Man, I wish I could paint my Norelco electric razor brown and pretend to temporarily disorient people with it”. Those that were, were probably also thinking “Wait, I’m nine, what the fuck am I doing with a Norelco razor?” right before they were beat with plastic extendable swords and given a swirly by the other, much cooler kids. This one goes to Star Wars.
Well, I think I’ll end it here with a tie for now. I’ll be popping in every so often with more of these, so stay tuned.